As water issues intensify, so does awareness of the effects of water management decisions. The methodology for defining spatial priorities for irrigation development. Planning theory identifies a stepwise process for making decisions which typically include the following steps. Land suitability analysis is a prerequisite to achieving optimum utilization of the available land resources. Water evaluation and planning system, gediz basin turkey. Developing a userbased decisionaid framework for water. Drip planning guide careful planning and quality products are the keys to a successful drip irrigation setup. A multi criteria decision tool for the assessment and. Application of spatial multicriteria analysis to site. The alse system was designed with specific knowledge based on gis and multi criteria for predicting the geoenvironmental suitability of land for cultivation of major crops in tropical and subtropical regions. Proposing an index to evaluate the groundwater quality. Governments must decide how to allocate limited resources for infrastructure development, particularly since financing gaps have been projected for the coming decades.
The solution to these complex decision problems requires the use of mathematical techniques that are formulated to take into account conflicting objectives. A new multicriteria decision making approach for sustainable material selection problem. It is a rational decisionmaking approach which simplifies complicated problems and breaks down into small parts into hierarchical structuring saaty 1985. Therefore, many researchers employ multicriteria decision making mcdm. The main objective of this study was to evaluate th e land suitability for cultivation of an economical ly important crop, which was rice, in amol district, iran. Mapping natural resources vulnerability to droughts using. Evaluation of potential irrigation expansion using a.
A critical study on rank reversal problem journal of cleaner production, vol. Mcdm finds the best options among the feasible alternatives in the presence of multiple, usually conflicting, and decision criteria. The management of river basins is complex especially when decisions about environmental flows are considered in addition to those concerning urban and agricultural water demand. This level is where most multi attribute decision analysis moda, mcda, mua, mau, etc. Software related to mcdm multiple criteria decision making. Prof nagesh and his team have developed algorithms and software that. To achieve this, the super decision software version 2. Decision matrix analysis decisionmaking skills from. This architecture supports a participatory approach involving local stake holders for multicriteria optimisation and decision support. Multiple criteria decision analysis software syncopation. Pdf irrigated agriculture has considerable impacts on the.
Development of a multi criteria decision making tool for a. The application of multicriteria analysis methods for the. Fuzzy multicriterion decision making in irrigation planning. Selection of the best compromise irrigation plan is examined in the multi objective context. A web based clientserver implementation supports distributed use and easy access, providing considerable server side computing power for distributed web browser clients. Mcda basically originated from operations research involving a wide range of methodologies, nevertheless with an amusing rational foundation in other disciplines. Chapter 2 planning project evaluation this chapter explains key issues to consider for evaluation planning. In irrigation planning, two fuzzy logicbased multicriterion decision making. The approach has widespread and growing application in the field of water resource management. Evaluation questions will be explained as the first step in making a work plan, and then, basis for judgment, necessary data and data sources, and data collection methods will follow. It finds that mca is being heavily used for water policy. Decision making in water management planning process is very complex. Monitoring and evaluation scheme using the multiplecriteriadecisionmaking technique. Irrigation decisions are made within a wider context.
Many optimization models exist for water management systems. The framework of the mcdm procedure in this extension software. Develop a hierarchy structure of the decision problem, i. Dexi software allows the display of results in multiple graphical modes. Multicriteria decision analysis applied to glen canyon dam. The integration of gis and the expert systems in alse enable decision making with spatial data. Multiple criteria analysis mca is a framework for ranking or scoring the overall performance of decision options against multiple objectives. In this study, a water resource management model that facilitates indicatorbased decisions, with respect to environmental, social and economic dimensions in a multiple criteria perspective, is developed for the gediz river basin in turkey.
The basic input of the proposed model is the quantity of surface water that is mainly allocated to irrigation purposes. We are seeing the growth of multicriteria decision making frameworks that can score different. In order to solve such complex problems concerning energy planning, multi criteria decision making mcdm is proved to be one of the better tool for efficient energy planning. Im an environmental manager and i need to decide how to clean up this contaminated site, trading off cost, public safety. Development of a multifunction software decision support. Multiobjective optimization also known as multiobjective programming, vector optimization, multicriteria optimization, multiattribute optimization or pareto optimization is an area of multiple criteria decision making that is concerned with mathematical optimization problems involving more than one objective function to be optimized simultaneously. Sophisticated mcda can involve highly complex modeling of different potential scenarios, using advanced mathematics.
Multi criteria decision making mcdm techniques serve as a promising method for the optimization of groundwater resources and its man agement by adding structure, auditability, transparency and. The scope of this work is to present the multicriteria analysis user friendly software that has been developed. Comparative study of different multicriteria decision. Fuzzy approach based management model for irrigation. The water evaluation and planning weap software is used as a simulation and. The techniques provide solutions to the problems involving conflicting and multiple objectives. Planning weap software is used as a simulation and evaluation tool to assess the performance of. How this simulation modeling tool makes decision making. Marinoni, o, a higgins, s hajkowicz and k collins 2009 the multiple criteria analysis tool mcat. There are multiple attributes and serious thought must be given to the tradeoffs among them in order to understand the objective function. A multi criteria analysis of water management strategies in the gediz basin. Users will be able to apply the tool for planning practices via scenario analysis or using the multi.
A fuzzy logicbased multicriterion decision making approach was applied. Fanp as multi criteria decision making tools were compared. The model has been applied under 3 different hydrometeorological scenarios that reflect baseline as well as better and worse conditions of water. Fuzzy multicriterion decision making in irrigation planning request. Land suitability analysis using geographic information. A multiobjective optimisation approach to water management. Afuzzy logic spatial decision support system for urban water management. Decision matrix analysis is the simplest form of multiple criteria decision analysis mcda, also known as multiple criteria decision aid or multiple criteria decision management mcdm. Multicriteria analysis for design of microirrigation. Both in australia and around the world economic pressures on farms, increasing competition for water and increasing recognition of the environmental impacts of irrigation on rivers, groundwater and dependent ecosystems all impact on the irrigation decision english et al. Use of multicriteria analysis method dexi to define priorities. The framework of the mcdm procedure in this extension software has a hierarchical. Directions for the use of the cropwat computer program are provided. In the gis software select the areas which are suitable for irrigation over longterm periods.
Comparative study of different multicriteria decisionmaking methods vyas gayatri s. The process was intended to be used by the park authorities for design and evaluation of proper sites in supporting decision making and dialog with the municipal councils. Mce is an effective tool for multiple criteria decisionmaking issues malczewski, 2006. Pdf the application of multicriteria analysis methods for the. This means that the goals andor the constraints constitute classes of alternatives whose boundaries are not sharply defined. It is not an exaggeration to argue that almost any local or federal government, industry, or business activity involves, in one way or the other, the evaluation of a set of alternatives in terms of a set of decision criteria. The process of ahp for solving problem is structured the decision problem in a hierarchical model establishing suitability criteria for built hillside development for example in fig. Multiple criteria decision making, multiattribute utility. A large number of tourists are oriented to hotel seeking sun and river 6. Defining spatial priorities for irrigation development. The tool is able to guide the responsible authorities to the most efficient solutions in terms of health and safety for the agricultural reuse of the produced effluent as well as to help them undertake actions that can be sustainable. Supporting the multicriteria decision aiding process. Land suitability analysis for rice cultivation using multi. Mcda basically originated from operations research involving a wide range of methodologies, nevertheless with an amusing rational foundation in other disciplines 7.
Several methods based on weighted averages, priority setting, outranking, fuzzy principles and their combinations are employed for energy planning decisions. A decision making tool for analytic hierarchy process ahp. Dexi software allows the display of results in multiple. In this study analytical hierarchy process ahp was used, ahp is known as a powerful.
Nagesh kumar 2 1 department of civil engineering, birla institute of. Multicriteria decision making mcdm methods are decision analysis tools that have been developed in order to support complex decision making kangas and kangas, 2002. Decisions at one point in the water cycle affect all the others from water supplies to treatment, conveyance, wastewater treatment, reuse and return to the natural environment and thats how the replica planner tool, part of jacobs suite of digital twins solutions software, makes a. Several biophysical, environmental and economical factors were selected based on the f ao. Multicriteria decision making mcdm techniques are gaining popularity in sustainable energy management. Multicriteria decisionmaking mcdm plays a critical role in many real life problems. Methods in this research, takestan irrigation and drainage network was chosen to find out the best water productivity factor. A spatial assessment of nipah virus transmission in. This guide provides all the information youll need in a very well written and laid out format. The water evaluation and planning weap software is used as a simulation. Thailands central plain is identified as a contact zone between pigs and flying foxes, representing a potential zoonotic risk. Multicriteria decision making for water resource management.
Nipah virus niv has been reported in flying foxes in thailand, but it has never been found in pigs or humans. The visualization capacities of the tool will facilitate a thorough assessment of the two scenarios, and will reveal the estimated costs and environmental benefits of practices. An assessment of the suitability of niv transmission at the spatial and farm level would be useful for disease surveillance and prevention. Analyses of complex water management decision making problems, involving tradeoffs amongst multiple criteria, are often undertaken using multi criteria decision analysis mcda techniques. Multi criteria decision making mcdm or multi criteria evaluation mce has been developed to improve spatial decision making when a set of alternatives need to be evaluated on the basis of conflicting and incommensurate criteria. Being able to tightly link with weap, this tool functions as extension software. The multicriteria analysis techniques can greatly reduce the cost and time and increase accuracy in decisionmaking. To ac hieve this goal, multicriteria decision making mc dm integrated with the gis was used to assess suitable areas for growing this crop. In irrigation planning, two fuzzy logicbased multicriterion decision making mcdm methods such as similarity analysis sa and decision analysis da have been used and developed as a fuzzy. Cropwat is a program for ibmpcs or compatibles to calculate reference evapotranspiration, crop water and irrigation requirements, and scheme water supply. A software workbench which helps to design, execute and share complex mcdam algorithms and experiments. Multicriterion decision making in irrigation planning citeseerx.
Site selection can be considered as a multiple criteria decision making or multiple mcdm problems involve a set of alternatives that are evaluated on the basis of spatial planning 2. In this paper we presented a new r package entitled rmcriteria that. Gisbased madm is used in a wide range of site selection decision 3, 4, 5. Lack of knowledge on best combination of factors that suit production of rice has contributed to the low production. Decisionmaking in a fuzzy environment management science. Decision support system, integrated water resources management, multi criteria analysis, decisionmaking, environmental modeling, world commission on dams, dam, dpsir. Multi criteria decision making for water resource management.
In the san francisco bay area, planning for nutrient management serves as an exemplary model of this transition. A new tool, spatial multi criteria decision making model smcdm, is developed for the wellknown water evaluation and planning system weap allocation model facilitating multi criteria decision making mcdm process. Definite decisions on a finite set of alternatives is a decision support software pack. Multicriteria decision making in hotel site selection. Multiple criteria decisionmaking process can be a very powerful tool for making irrigation plans, said an iisc official. Multicriteria analysis mca provides a systematic methodology to. Ten alternative irrigated agricultural production systems. By decisionmaking in a fuzzy environment is meant a decision process in which the goals andor the constraints, but not necessarily the system under control, are fuzzy in nature.
469 1089 400 1484 491 560 624 1123 1371 1485 18 1195 933 613 903 830 1369 1186 1544 14 1609 166 453 1532 297 1114 715 284 1204 375 1023 1492 762 107 892 378 1187 793 1041 423